PlanPhilly

SEPTA may purchase bi-level coaches

Things are looking up for regional rail. 

In an attempt to increase passenger capacity, SEPTA is in the early stages of considering bi-level coaches. With an upstairs and a downstairs, these coaches could transport anywhere from 120 to 170 passengers. Most important to SEPTA, they would provide an efficient remedy to booming regional rail ridership. Silverliner Vs can seat 109 passengers.

Last year alone, SEPTA passengers took 36 million regional rail trips - a record high on the system that has seen 50 percent regional rail ridership growth in the last 15 years. Now, aided by Act 89 funding, SEPTA is looking to increase its capacity and better serve those customers. One way the authority plans to do so is to build up. 

"The real elegant solution to dealing with capacity issues, the most efficient one is to utilize the infrastructure you have but go up in the air with the cars so you can increase seating," said Jeff Knueppel, deputy general manager. 

With more passengers, the regional rail network needs more seats. One option might be to add more cars to the trains that are already running, but that would require longer platforms that would only be used during rush hour. Plus, in areas like the section between Wayne Junction and Glenside stations, SEPTA has two tracks and more than 100 trains scheduled on each track during rush hour. Lengthening those trains could lead to traffic jams. 

Instead, SEPTA is looking to bi-level coaches, similar to those New Jersey Transit (NJT) and Massachusetts Bay Transit Authority (MBTA) are already using. NJT's coaches carry between 120 to 140 passengers, and MBTA's cars carry up to about 170 passengers. 

CLEARANCE

One big question is: Will bi-level coaches fit on SEPTA's system?

"It's very challenging, and if you were to stand on the platform at Market East and look at a single-level train, you'd think to yourself, how are you going to get another level?" Knueppel said. 

SEPTA is conducting a clearance study, and while that study is not complete, solutions to low clearance might include "slick design" of the coaches, moving the catenary wires or lowering portions of the track. Knueppel said it does not appear that increasing clearances in this way would require very expensive projects.

SEATING

At this point, SEPTA is looking to procure about 36 bi-level coaches. The authority has not decided on what seating arrangement it will go with though, so it is unclear how many additional seats the fleet will provide.

"We're looking to carry more [passengers] per car, but we don't want to go crazy with trying to cram people into cars," Knueppel said.

COST

SEPTA is assuming the coaches will cost somewhere between $2.5 million and $3 million per car.

In comparison, the Silverliner Vs cost SEPTA an average of approximately $2.3 million per vehicle, but the price has since gone up. Hyundai Rotem, which manufactured SEPTA's Silverliner Vs, is working on similar vehicles for the commuter rail system in Denver. That $200 million contract for 50 vehicles puts the current average cost of a Silverliner V in the $4 million range. 

"It's a very efficient solution," Knueppel said. "They are cheaper. They provide more seating, and you're not maintaining motors on everyone of the cars."

Electric Locomotives

Procuring the bi-level coaches is slated for phase one of SEPTA's "Catching Up" plan, the capital improvement plan targeting the system's most pressing needs. Also in phase one, SEPTA plans to procure new electric locomotives, which will increase that fleet from eight to 12. The electric locomotives, along with SEPTA's 53 push-pull locomotives, are used to move passenger coaches throughout the system, and these new electric locomotives will replace SEPTA's current AEM-7 electric locomotives, built in 1987. 

Knueppel said the new locomotives will be "a quantum leap forward from the AEM-7s."

If things go well, SEPTA may issue a proposal for the locomotives this year. Shortly after that, SEPTA would work on a proposal for the bi-level coaches. 

In later phases of “Catching Up,” SEPTA will procure new trolleys and Silverliner VIs.

"I know the issue has been around core infrastructure and existing things, but at the same time, people would be very critical of us if we weren't also… looking to do a certain portion of work in areas that would allow us to keep expanding ridership on the railroad," Knueppel said. 


About the author

Christine Fisher, Transportation reporter

Christine covers transportation and writes about everything from pedestrian concerns to bicycle infrastructure, bridges, trail networks, public transit and more. Her favorite assignments send her bushwhacking through Philadelphia’s yet-to-be-cleared bike trails, catching a glimpse of SEPTA’s inner workings or pounding the pavement to find out what pedestrians really think. Christine also covers community news for Eyes on the Street, where her coverage ranges from food sovereignty to public art and urban greening. She first joined PlanPhilly in fall 2011 as an intern through a partnership with Temple University’s Philadelphia Neighborhoods website. During the internship her reporting on the Housing Authority’s surplus property auctions earned an award from the Society of Professional Journalists.



blog comments powered by Disqus

Logging in via Facebook

Log in

Subscribe to the PlanPhilly Mailing List