PlanPhilly

This e-scooter wants to defeat Philly’s potholes

Philadelphia’s rough streets may demand a brawnier breed of e-scooter.

The electric gliders, known for their slim profile, aren’t even street legal in Pennsylvania but that isn’t stopping one company, Lime, from rolling out a new 60-pound model designed with rough city streets in mind.

The Lime-S Gen 3 scooter boasts a heavier frame, wider footboard, front and back brakes, shock absorbers, and 10-inch wheels.  

“As well as anything can withstand these mean Philly streets, I think our green guys are ready for it,” Shari Shapiro, the company’s director of Mid-Atlantic government said on Thursday at a public demo of the devices at City Hall. The company is one of several likely to eventually compete for a limited number of licenses to operate in the city.

On smooth ground, Lime’s ride isn’t too bad from the perspective of a 5’10, 210-pound male. Just kick start, and let the breeze caress your face. But there’s no telling if the scooter can truly take a pounding from the pavement. Not even this reporter could get the green light for a test ride on Philly streets.

That could change by fall, if legislation introduced in Harrisburg gets the votes needed to legalize e-scooters. But even if the bill makes it out of the statehouse, it’ll be some time before the devices are zipping through Philly. City officials recommended taking a year to study safety and other “benefits and risks” at a hearing in February.

“We’re not going to be moving particularly speedily,”  Aaron Ritz, transportation systems manager for the city’s Office of Transportation, Infrastructure, and Sustainability, said Thursday. “We’re going to be moving thoughtfully and carefully as we consider a new transportation option. We recognize that everything is more complicated once you get past the surface level.”

    • PlanPhilly reporter Darryl C. Murphy scoots through City Hall's courtyard. (Kim Paynter/WHYY)
      PlanPhilly reporter Darryl C. Murphy scoots through City Hall's courtyard. (Kim Paynter/WHYY)

A recent study of scooter users in Austin,Texas found a third of 190 riders who reported being injured on scooters were injured during their first ride, and 29 percent had drank alcohol in the 12 hours prior to getting hurt. Of these 190 injured riders, 48 percent suffered injuries to the head, 15 percent of which suffered brain trauma. The study said these were preventable, as only one out of the 190 was wearing a helmet when the injury occured,

Shapiro acknowledges that accidents happen on e-scooters but said the peril is no comparison to cars, the  “the most dangerous and most deadly” vehicle. There are simple ways to prevent injuries, she said.

“Be safe, wear a helmet, follow the rules of the road, don’t drink and scoot,” she said.

Scooter advocates argue that the devices reduce car use, A study  touted by industry representatives  found that 34 percent of Portland users took e-scooters as an alternative to a car, taxi, or ride-hail, reducing congestion and the dangers posed by traffic.

For now, area residents can legally scoot in New Jersey if they’re willing to travel to Hoboken, where their e-scooter pilot program featuring Lime and OjO Electric has logged over 20,000 rides since May 21.

About the author

Darryl C. Murphy, staff reporter

Darryl C. Murphy is PlanPhilly's transportation and mobility reporter. He is a 2017 graduate of Temple University and originally from South Jersey.



blog comments powered by Disqus

Article Information

Recent Comments on PlanPhilly

Powered by Disqus

Subscribe to our mailing list

* indicates required
Which weekly emails would you like to receive?